• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
The BarBend Logo in white.

BarBend

The Online Home for Strength Sports

  • News
    • CrossFit
    • Strongman
    • Bodybuilding
    • Top Athletes
    • Powerlifting
    • Weightlifting
    • HYROX
    • Competition Results
    • Latest Research
  • Reviews
    • Recovery
      • Best Cold Plunges
      • Best Saunas
      • Best Mini Massage Guns
      • Individual Recovery Reviews
    • Supplements
      • Best Protein
        • Best Whey Protein Powders
        • Best Vegan Protein Powders
        • Best Whey Isolate Protein Powders
        • Best Mass Gainers
        • Best Protein Bars
      • Best Pre-Workouts
        • Best Pre-Workouts for Women
        • Best Pre-Workouts for Men
        • Best Non-Stim Pre-Workouts
        • Strongest Pre-Workouts
      • Best Creatine
      • Best Electrolyte Supplements
      • Best Greens Powder
      • Best Meal Replacements
      • Best Nitric Oxide Supplements
      • Best Fat Burners
        • Best Fat Burners for Men
        • Best Fat Burners for Women
        • Best Non-Stim Fat Burners
      • More Supplements
        • Best Supplements for Muscle Growth
        • Best Supplements for CrossFit
        • Best Supplements for Weight Loss
        • Best Supplements for Bodybuilding
        • Best Supplements for Men
        • Best Supplement Stacks
      • Individual Supplements Reviews
    • Equipment
      • Cardio
        • Best Treadmills
        • Best Rowing Machines
        • Best Exercise Bikes
        • Best Ellipticals
        • Best Recumbent Bikes
      • Strength
        • Best Adjustable Dumbbells
        • Best Dumbbells
        • Best Kettlebells
        • Best Barbells
        • Best Squat Racks
        • Best Free Weights
        • Best Weight Benches
        • Best Resistance Bands
        • Best Slam Balls
        • Best Weighted Vests
        • Best Leg Extension Machines
        • Best Cable Machines
        • Best Power Racks
        • Best Pull Up Bars
      • Best Home Gyms
        • Best Smart Home Gyms
        • Best Gym Equipment Under $100
        • Best Home Gym Essentials
        • Best Home Gym Flooring
      • Individual Equipment Reviews
    • Fitness Accessories
      • Apparel
        • Best Weightlifting Shoes
        • Best Cross Training Shoes
        • Best Gym Bags
        • Best Gym Shorts
      • Training
        • Best Weightlifting Belts
        • Best Knee Sleeves
        • Best Lifting Straps
        • Best Grip Strengtheners
        • Best Wrist Wraps
        • Best Lifting Gloves
      • Individual Fitness Product Reviews
    • Certifications
      • Best Sports Nutrition Certifications
      • Best Personal Trainer Certifications
      • Best Nutrition Certifications
      • Individual Certifications Reviews
    • Programs
      • Best Online Workout Programs
      • Best Workout Streaming Services
      • Best Home Workout Programs
      • Individual Program Reviews
  • Nutrition
    • Diets
      • Carb Cycling
      • Vertical Diet
      • Reverse Dieting
      • Carnivore Diet
      • Ketogenic Diet
      • Intermittent Fasting
      • IIFYM Diet
    • Fat Loss
      • Macros for Fat Loss
      • Calorie Deficits
      • Natural Fat Burners
      • Cut 2 Pounds Weekly
    • Muscle Gain
      • How to Dirty Bulk
      • Go From Cutting to Bulking
      • Eat These Carbs
      • How to Eat for Muscle
    • Supplement Guides
      • Pre-Workout
      • Whey Protein
      • Mass Gainers
      • Greens Powders
      • Creatine
      • BCAAs
    • Nutrition Tips
      • Daily Protein Needs
      • Pre- and Post-Workout Nutrition
      • Foods With Creatine
      • Bulking Tips
  • Training
    • Workouts
      • Back Workouts
      • At-Home Workouts
      • Chest & Back Workouts
      • Full-Body Workout
      • HIIT Workouts
    • Exercise Guides
      • Deadlift
      • Bench Press
      • Back Squat
      • Overhead Press
      • Bent-Over Row
      • Lat Pulldown
      • Crunches
      • Farmer’s Carry
    • Best Exercises
      • Shoulder Exercises
      • Back Exercises
      • Chest Exercises
      • Glute Exercises
      • Ab Exercises
      • Hamstring Exercises
      • Quad Exercises
      • Calf Exercises
      • Biceps Exercises
      • Triceps Exercises
    • Programs
      • Push-Up Program
      • Pull-Up Program
      • German Volume Training
      • 5/3/1 Program
      • Powerbuilding Program
      • The Cube Method
      • 5×5 Program
      • Bodybuilding Programs
      • Build Your Own Program
    • Fat Loss
      • How to Burn Fat
      • Spot Fat Reduction
      • How to Train on a Cut
      • Body Conditioning
      • Workouts
        • Kettlebell Circuits
        • Dumbbell Complexes
        • Farmer’s Carry Workouts
    • Muscle Gain
      • Muscle Hypertrophy Explained
      • How to Build Muscle
      • How to Maintain Muscle
      • What Researchers Say About Muscle Gain
        • Workouts
          • 20-Minute Workouts
          • Kettlebell Circuits
          • CrossFit Workouts for Muscle
          • Bodybuilding Workouts
  • Calculators
    • Protein Intake Calculator
    • Macros Calculator
    • BMR Calculator
    • Squat Calculator
    • Calorie Calculator
Roundups

10 Best Meal Replacement Shakes of 2024, With Dietitian Advice

Whether you’re cutting weight or bulking up, these are our favorite meal replacements on the market today.

Written by Nick English
Updated by Bojana Galic on August 20th, 2024
Expert VerifiedExpert Verified By: Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, MS, RDN, LD
Expert VerifiedExpert Contributor: Jake Herod, NASM-CNC
Expert VerifiedReviewed By: Lauren Keary

We receive free products and receive commissions through our links. See disclosures page.
  • Top Meal Replacements
  • |
  • Video Review
  • |
  • Benefits of Meal Replacements
  • |
  • Meal Replacement Prices
  • |
  • How We Picked
  • |
  • What to Consider

Whether you’re a high-calorie-burning athlete who needs to stay fueled or a gym goer looking to hit your daily macros, a meal replacement shake may do the trick. Generally, meal replacements are full of protein, carbs, fats, and vitamins to fuel your body with what it needs. And much like the best protein powders, they’re way more convenient than breaking out a full recipe when you’re in a pinch for sustenance.

When it comes to choosing the best meal replacement shake, it’s important to find a product based on your personal preferences and fitness goals. That’s why, after trying many, many meal replacements ourselves, our team of experts landed on a wide selection of the best meal replacement shakes that suit a variety of nutritional needs and dietary goals.

Best Meal Replacement Shakes of 2024

  • Best Meal Replacement Shake: Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal
  • Best Meal Replacement Shake for Weight Gain: Transparent Labs Mass Gainer
  • Best Vegan Meal Replacement Shake: Rootana
  • Best Keto Meal Replacement Shake: HLTH Code Complete Meal
  • Best Meal Replacement Shake for Weight Loss: Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal
  • Best Meal Replacement Bar: Legion High Protein Bar
  • Best-Tasting Meal Replacement Shake: Huel Black Edition
  • Best High-Protein Meal Replacement: Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal
  • Best Meal Replacement Shake for Diabetes:310 Meal Replacement Shake
  • Best Organic Meal Replacement Shake: Orgain Vegan Organic Nutrition Shake

Note: The content on BarBend is meant to be informative in nature, but it shouldn’t take the place of qualified medical advice. If you’re looking to make a significant change to your diet and training regimen or replace a significant percentage of your food with meal replacements, please consult your medical professional first.

Experts Who Contributed

  • Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, MS, RDN, LD
  • Jake Herod, NASM-CNC
  • Alex Polish, ACE-CPT

Best Meal Replacements Video Review

Join BarBend expert tester Jake Herod, NASM-CNC, and registered dietitian nutritionist Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, MS, RDN, LD, as they break down our picks for the best-tasting meal replacements, from the best shakes and bars to options suited for weight gain and vegan diets.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_N9oRt9Lto

How We Tested and Chose the Best Meal Replacements

Meal replacement shakes vary enormously concerning the nutrition they provide. In order to provide a well-rounded list, our team of BarBend experts, including athletes and personal trainers, tested more than 10 products, considering all the ingredients one might need. Using our supplement testing methodology, these are the factors we used to make our picks: 

  • Macronutrients: A good meal replacement has balanced nutrients, otherwise you can be left feeling hungry. We prioritized products that offered a good balance of carbs, fat, and protein, unless it was tailored to a specific diet.
  • Vitamins and Nutrients: There are 13 essential vitamins, including vitamin A, C, D, E, K and the B vitamins. (6) We picked meal replacement shakes that help tick those boxes. We also tried to pick products that packed fiber, another essential nutrient.
  • Minerals: As with your vitamins, we wanted to make sure you’re getting the minerals you need to keep your body functioning at its best. We prioritized formulas that offer ample mineral content, like calcium, potassium, and magnesium.
BarBend testers trying the Ka'Chava meal replacement shake.
BarBend testers trying the Ka’Chava meal replacement shake.
  • Taste and Texture: So, we browsed countless customer reviews to offer products that dissolve well and actually taste appetizing. Everyone’s taste is different, we know, so we also tried to prioritize products that offer several flavor options.

[Related: 8 Best Protein Shakes of 2024 (Tested by Experts)]

Best Meal Replacement Shake Overall: Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal

Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal
Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal
Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal

This vegan meal replacement offers various superfood blends that include organic fruits, vegetables, mushrooms, enzymes and probiotics. It totals 240 calories, 25 grams of plant-based protein, 25 grams of carbohydrates (including seven grams of fiber), and seven grams of fat. 

Shop Ka'Chava

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 240 calories
  • Macros: 7-8g of fat, 21-24g of carbs, 25g of protein
  • Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Coconut Acai, Chai, Matcha
  • Fiber per Serving: 4-7 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 6-7 grams
  • Price per Serving: $4.66

Pros

  • Balanced macros
  • Includes probiotic/prebiotic blends
  • 25g of carbs for post-workout fuel

Cons

  • Pricey
  • Others are more calorie-dense

The best meal replacement shake on our list boasts a formula that may help with digestion and satiation, as well as recovery — plus, it tastes delicious and contains no synthetic/artificial fillers, creamers, or soy protein, making it our absolute top pick.

Ka’Chava’s Whole Body Meal certainly checks a lot of boxes, earning an overall 4.5 out of 5 from our RD, Chelsea Rae Bourgeois. “I like what Ka’Chava offers with their Whole Body Meal Shake,” Bourgeois says. “You get a good balance of macronutrients and a really impressive list of vitamins and minerals. Plus, it provides a good amount of dietary fiber per serving — yay, gut health!”

That said, the 240 calorie count per serving is a bit lighter than other meal replacements on the market and cannot serve as a full meal replacement. The satiation is in part due to the macros here, which include seven grams of fat, 25 grams of carbs, and 25 grams of protein per serving for the Chocolate flavor (the exact macros vary slightly, depending on the flavor you choose). The probiotics can also help your body digest this supplement, as it may assist your gut microbiome in eliminating bad bacteria. (1) 

A BarBend tester trying the Ka'Chava shake.
A BarBend tester trying the Ka’Chava shake.

“This is one of the best meal replacements I’ve tried,” our tester said, giving this product a 4 out of 5 for flavor. “It has a slightly earthy flavor but it’s barely noticeable and I didn’t notice too much grittiness either. It’s one of the better plant-based shakes I’ve had.”

For this shake, you will want to have a blender handy, as a shaker bottle just won’t cut it. But after blending it with water, our tester loved the consistency. They also experienced zero side effects after sipping this product.

For overall value, we gave Ka’Chava’s Whole Body Meal a 4 out of 5. One 15-serving back is $69.95, which is about $4.66 per serving. This is certainly pricey, but we still gave a pretty high rating in this category because of the high-quality ingredients. “It’s definitely expensive but you’re paying for good ingredients with a lot of nutritional value,” our tester said.

Read our full Ka’Chava Meal Replacement Review.

Best Meal Replacement for Weight Gain: Transparent Labs Mass Gainer

10% Off
Transparent Labs Mass Gainer
Transparent Labs Mass Gainer
Transparent Labs Mass Gainer

With nothing artificial, whey from New Zealand, a good amount of fiber, and little sugar, this mass gainer will satisfy most athletes. It's a clean mass gainer that focuses on simplicity over added bells and whistles.

Shop Transparent Labs

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 730-750 calories
  • Macros: 13-14g of fat, 106-110g of carbs, 51-53g of protein
  • Flavors: Chocolate Glaze Donut, Sweet Vanilla
  • Fiber per Serving: 4-6 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 12 grams
  • Price per Serving: $5.33

Pros

  • High calories per serving
  • No artificial flavors, colors, or sweeteners
  • Includes the daily recommended three grams of creatine. (7)

Cons

  • Very calorie dense
  • Lacks many micronutrients

One of our best mass gainers, this pick packs 53 grams of protein, 14 grams of fat, and 110 grams of carbs per serving. “Transparent Labs Mass Gainer scores a 4.25 out of 5 for formulation,” according to Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, RDN. “It accomplishes exactly what it’s intended to accomplish, and the ingredients list is very transparent.” 

Alongside the macro counts, the product even includes MCTs, coconut milk powder, and a serving of creatine monohydrate (which can help with strength and power production). “Two things give me pause, it’s the sodium and saturated fat contents,” Bourgeois says. “There’s a lot to unpack but to keep it short, if heart health is a concern, you should be mindful of how frequently you use this powder.”

“The Chocolate Glazed Donut flavor was exactly as described,” according to our tester, who gave the taste a 4 out of 5. Our team does wish there were more variety, as your only other option is Sweet Vanilla. Nevertheless, the taste was rich and creamy.

A BarBend tester trying Transparent Labs Mass Gainer.
A BarBend tester trying Transparent Labs Mass Gainer.

We gave TL’s powder a 4.5 out of 5 for solubility, too. “This product dissolved well and I noticed no clumps,” our tester said. “I also enjoyed the consistency.” They also noticed no negative side effects after sipping this supplement.

After comparing this mass gainer to others on the market, we gave the overall value a 3 out of 5. Most other mass gainers and meal replacements cost less than $5 per serving, placing this product on the pricey side at $5.33 per serving. Unfortunately, this may not be affordable for all athletes, but luckily, there are more budget-friendly picks on this list.

Read our full Transparent Labs Mass Gainer Review.

Best Vegan Meal Replacement Shake: Rootana

Rootana
Rootana
Rootana

Rootana is a plant-based, vegan-friendly meal replacement shake packed with over 20 percent of your daily needs of 27 different vitamins and minerals. The macro profile is diet-friendly with 20g of protein, 44g of carbs (8g of fiber), and 14g of omega-rich fats for the original flavor. Other flavors are Vanilla and Dark Chocolate.

Shop Rootana

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 400 calories
  • Macros: 14g of fat, 44-46g of carbs, 20g of protein
  • Flavors: Original, Vanilla, Dark Chocolate
  • Fiber per Serving: 7-9 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 12 grams
  • Price per Serving: $3.78

Pros

  • 100 percent vegan-friendly
  • Contains 27 vitamins and minerals
  • Includes omegas 3, 6, and 9

Cons

  • Not gluten-free
  • Difficult to mix without blender

For folks who are more health-conscious or need to increase their micronutrient intake, we’ve found a formula that offers a tremendous amount of vitamins and minerals, contains no refined carbs, and has valuable extras — meet Rootana’s meal replacement. 

After reviewing the ingredients and nutrition label, our team gave this formula an overall 4 out of 5. Each 400-calorie serving of the Original flavor (which is lightly sweetened) provides 20 grams of protein, 14 grams of fats rich in omegas 3, 6, and 9, and 44 grams of unrefined carbs (with 8 grams of fiber). This uses pea protein, which is a complete protein, unlike other plants.

The micronutrient profile is where Rootana shines through, with at least 20 percent of your recommended daily intake of 27 different vitamins and minerals — these include B vitamins like folate, vitamin D, calcium, potassium, iron, chromium, zinc, and more.

Rootana Meal Replacement Powder
BarBend tester trying Rootana Meal Replacement.

“The chocolate flavor wasn’t terrible but I would say it’s just OK,” according to our tester, who gave the flavor a 3 out of 5. “I’ve tasted better but I’ve definitely had worse, too. I wish it had tasted a little sweeter.” However, we didn’t try any of the other flavors, so it’s hard to give a perfect flavor review.

One area that could use improvement was solubility. “I followed the mixing directions but it was so thick,” our tester said, giving the texture a 2 out of 5. “Using more water makes it better but then you don’t get a totally accurate portion.” 

Rootana meal replacement in BarBend testing garage

For value, we gave Rootana a 4 out of 5. One 14-serving bag costs $52.99, which is about $3.78 per meal. However, you can subscribe and get an extra 15 percent off each delivery. Compared to other meal replacement shakes, this one sits in the middle of the road. You can find more expensive and cheaper products on the market.

[Related: The 3 Most Common Types Of Training Periodization (And When To Use Them)]

Best Keto Meal Replacement Shake: HLTH Code Complete Meal

15% OFF with code BARBEND
HLTH Code Complete Meal
HLTH Code Complete Meal
HLTH Code Complete Meal

HLTH Code is delicious, offers 27 grams of protein with 400 calories, and contains up to 25 vitamins and minerals.  It's also insanely satiating, which means you're getting a lot of bang for your buck with each serving. Save 15% with code BARBEND.

Shop HLTH Code

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 400 calories
  • Macros: 27g of fat, 13g of carbs, 27g of protein
  • Flavors: Chocolate Macadamia, Creamy Vanilla
  • Fiber per Serving: 9 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 2 grams
  • Price per Serving: $4

Pros

  • Keto-friendly formula
  • Includes omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids
  • Chocolate and vanilla flavors available

Cons

  • Very low carb
  • High fat content
  • Few flavor options

We’ve tried many keto-focused meal replacements, but we found HLTH Code’s Complete Meal to be head and shoulders above the rest. For a keto-focused product, this formula is a bit different from the average. More than half of the calories are from fat, with another quarter coming from protein, so dieters who follow a high-fat diet can take this supplement without exiting ketosis.

It also has both omega-3 and omega-6 fats, MCT powder (which is part of its Healthy Fats Blend and may help you stay in ketosis), and collagen. Plus, it is free of GMOs and is made in an FDA-approved facility. Also, HLTH Code has 13 grams of carbs and nine grams of fiber, equating to only four net carbs. 

Nevertheless, our RD had to give this meal replacement powder a 2 out of 5. “This meal replacement shake is not for those who want a well-balanced meal,” according to Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, RD. “Each serving of HLTH Code Complete Meal provides an alarming amount of saturated fat and a wildly insufficient amount of carbs.” 

Chocolate Macadamia HLTH Code Complete Meal
HLTH shake in BarBend testing gym.

Although it doesn’t provide the complete nutrition of a meal, Bourgeois did like that this shake doesn’t contain any sugar at all. Instead, it uses low-glycemic monk fruit extract and stevia to give it a sweet flavor. 

Unfortunately, we had to give the flavor variety a 2 out of 5. This product only comes in Chocolate Macadamia and Creamy Vanilla. Some athletes may want a little more variety if they’re going to drink this shake every day.

When it comes to overall value, we gave HLTH Code a 3 out of 5. A 15-serving bag costs $59.95, which is about $4 per meal. This isn’t as expensive as some meal replacements, but you can still find cheaper alternatives.

[Related: Intermittent Fasting 101: A Guide To Benefits, Muscle Gain, and More]

Best Meal Replacement Shake for Weight Loss: Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal

Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal
Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal
Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal

This vegan meal replacement offers various superfood blends that include organic fruits, vegetables, mushrooms, enzymes and probiotics. It totals 240 calories, 25 grams of plant-based protein, 25 grams of carbohydrates (including seven grams of fiber), and seven grams of fat. 

Shop Ka'Chava

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 240 calories
  • Macros: 7-8g of fat, 21-24g of carbs, 25g of protein
  • Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Coconut Acai, Chai, Matcha
  • Fiber per Serving: 4-7 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 6-7 grams
  • Price per Serving: $4.66

Pros

  • Only 240 calories per serving
  • Contains micronutrients
  • Packs 21 percent of your daily fiber

Cons

  • Not budget-friendly
  • Low in carbs

Meal replacements are often used in weight loss efforts, and research supports their efficacy. (3) At only 240 calories per serving, Ka’Chava’s Whole Body Meal is our favorite meal replacement for weight loss. Its 25 grams of protein is enough to curb your appetite, and you get six grams of fiber (about 21 percent of the daily value), which may help boost satiety. After reviewing the ingredients, our team gave this formulation a 4 out of 5. 

The micronutrient profile is where this shake does well, supplying at least 25 percent of your daily value in several essential vitamins and minerals — like vitamins A, C, E, K, and D, and the B vitamins. 

You can get this shake in a variety of delicious flavors, including Vanilla, Chocolate, Coconut Acai, Chai, and Matcha. “The chocolate flavor is definitely chocolatey,” our tester said, giving the taste a 4 out of 5. “It’s not as earthy as some other plant-based supplements and it’s overall pretty good.”

A BarBend tester opening a bag of Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal.
A BarBend tester opening a bag of Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal.

For solubility, our tester gave this shake a 4.5 out of 5. However, we did use a blender while testing this product, and it’s probably your best bet. “One downside is that re-sealing the bag was tricky,” our tester explained. “I’m not sure if it’s just my specific bag but I had to use a grocery clip to keep it closed.”

This product sits on the pricey side. One 15-serving bag costs $69.95, which is about $4.66 per serving. However, you do get many high-quality ingredients, which we appreciate. Nevertheless, if this doesn’t fall in your budget, you can find cheaper options on this list. 

[Related: The Lifter’s Guide To Magnesium: What This Nutrient Does For Strength]

Best Meal Replacement Bar: Legion High Protein Bar

Legion Protein Bars
Legion Protein Bars
Legion Protein Bars

Legion High-Protein Bar has 20g of protein, 24g of carbs, and 12 grams of fat per bar. It slots in at 240 calories, and there’s only 4g of sugar per bar, which is pretty low considering some bars have up to 20g. Plus, the protein comes from a combination of whey protein isolate and whey protein concentrate, which makes for a balanced, stable blend.

Shop Legion

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 240-250 calories
  • Macros: 6-12g of fat, 24-38g of carbs, 20g of protein
  • Flavors: Blueberry Muffin, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Jelly, S’mores
  • Fiber per Serving: 8-10 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 4-7 grams
  • Price per Serving: $3.33

Pros

  • Calorie-dense for a bar
  • Well-balanced macronutrients
  • Convenient on-the-go

Cons

  • Can’t fully replace a meal
  • Not keto-friendly

Protein bars are a great meal replacement option for anyone on the go — they’re easy to travel with, and you can simply throw them in your gym bag for a post-workout pick-me-up. This pick checks a lot of essential boxes when you need a quick meal on the go.

“Legion High Protein Bars harness the goodness of all-natural ingredients to provide a hefty dose of protein, carbs, and fat,” according to Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, RD, who gave the formulation a 4 out of 5. These bars pack 20 grams of whey protein concentrate, 24 to 38 grams of carbs, and 11 to 12 grams of fat, depending on the flavor. 

The lower calorie count of 240 to 250 calories per bar is less than most meals/meal replacements, so this would count as a small meal or snack. Despite that, the friendly macro split of about 2:2:1 protein to carbs to fat replicates a meal’s macro profile well. However, each bar does have four grams of added sugar, Bourgeois points out, but this isn’t an alarming amount.

Legion High-Protein Bar in BarBend testing gym
Legion protein bars in BarBend testing gym.

“I tried both the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and the Chocolate Peanut Butter and I definitely preferred the peanut butter version,” our tester said, giving the flavor an overall 4 out of 5. “The chocolate didn’t shine through as much with the cookie dough.”

Unfortunately, we had to give this bar a 3 out of 5 for texture. “It looks like a moist and chewy protein bar but it was actually drier than I’d hoped,” our tester said. “It sticks in your teeth and it’s a lot like a Lara Bar but maybe even a little drier. It’s also very dense.”

One bar costs about $3.33, which is $39.99 for a 12-bar box. Compared to other protein bars on the market, this is pretty standard, earning Legion a 4 out of 5 for price per serving.

Best-Tasting Meal Replacement Shake: Huel Black Edition

Huel Black Edition
Huel Black Edition
Huel Black Edition

Huel Black Edition is a completely plant-based meal replacement that's loaded with vitamins and minerals. You can also choose from a wide variety of flavor options.

Shop Huel

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 400 calories
  • Macros: 17-18g of fat, 20-25g of carbs, 40g of protein
  • Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Banana, Strawberry Shortcake, Coffee Caramel, Cookies & Cream, Salted Caramel, Cinnamon Roll, Unflavored & Unsweetened
  • Fiber per Serving: 6-8 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 1-5 grams
  • Price per Serving: $2.50-$2.74

Pros

  • Great texture and taste
  • Budget-friendly
  • Totally plant-based

Cons

  • Not third-party tested
  • Includes added sugar

As you may notice, meal replacements don’t usually have a ton of flavor variety. But Huel Black Edition certainly doesn’t fall in that category. This shake comes in nine options, and our testers loved the taste. “I tried the Cookies & Cream and thought it had the perfect level of sweetness,” according to our tester, who gave the overall flavor a 5 out of 5. “I loved adding this to my coffee and it made my espresso taste even more delicious.”

BarBend tester trying the Huel Black Edition

For the overall formulation, our team gave Huel a 5 out of 5. One serving totals 400 calories, including a hefty dose of 40 grams of protein, 20 to 25 grams of carbs, and 17 to 18 grams of fat, depending on the flavor. You also get up to 71 percent of your daily vitamin C, 20 percent of your daily calcium, and 50 percent of your daily iron, among 24 other must-have micronutrients.

“This product dissolved pretty well, which I liked,” our tester said, giving the solubility a 4.5 out of 5. “However, I can taste some of the graininess from the powder when I just mixed it with water. With a blender and some ice, it was much better and undetectable.”

After taking Huel for several weeks, our tester noticed no negative side effects, giving a 5 out of 5 in this category. Their partner, who generally has GI issues with whey, also didn’t have any tummy troubles after trying this product, as it’s a whey protein isolate, meaning there’s very little lactose.

Unfortunately, we gave Huel a 3.5 out of 5 for third-party testing, as it doesn’t seem that the brand works with any labs. For athletes who compete at a professional level, this may be an issue. But we do like the transparency on the label and website.

This product is a little pricey, though. One 17-serving bag costs up to $46.50, which is about $2.74 per serving. While you can find cheaper options, this still isn’t the most expensive option on this list. And considering the high calorie count, $2.74 as a true meal replacement isn’t too shabby.

[Related: Best Clean Protein Powders]

Best High-Protein Meal Replacement Shake: Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal

Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal
Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal
Ka'Chava Whole Body Meal

This vegan meal replacement offers various superfood blends that include organic fruits, vegetables, mushrooms, enzymes and probiotics. It totals 240 calories, 25 grams of plant-based protein, 25 grams of carbohydrates (including seven grams of fiber), and seven grams of fat. 

Shop Ka'Chava

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 240 calories
  • Macros: 7-8g of fat, 21-24g of carbs, 25g of protein
  • Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Coconut Acai, Chai, Matcha
  • Fiber per Serving: 4-7 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 6-7 grams
  • Price per Serving: $4.66

Pros

  • High in protein, low in calories.
  • Only five to six grams of added sugar
  • Provides all nine essential amino acids

Cons

  • Low in calories
  • Relatively pricey

While this pick still offers healthy, whole ingredients and extra minerals, it packs 25 grams of protein into each meal. “Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal scores a 4.5 out of 5 for its formulation,” according to Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, RD. “You get a good balance of micronutrients and a really impressive list of vitamins and minerals.” Given the macros, this is ideal for those who are looking for a meal replacement that doubles as a protein supplement. 

Unfortunately, we did have to dock Ka’Chava a little because it only supplies 240 calories per serving. Realistically, this total isn’t sufficient to replace an actual meal, though we do love the nutrients one serving provides.

“I tried the Chai flavor and I like it,” our tester said, giving the taste a 4 out of 5. “It’s a nice change from the usual chocolate and vanilla options you see with meal replacements. It’s a little too flavorful for every day but once in a while, it’s great.” However, we did give the solubility and texture a 3 out of 5, as it’s a little gritty, which some athletes may not like.

A BarBend tester reading the Ka'Chava ingredient label.
A BarBend tester reading the Ka’Chava ingredient label.

The side effects are worth noting, though, as we gave a 3.5 out of 5 in this category. Our tester did notice a little bloating after sipping the Whole Body Meal (nothing extreme). However, this is likely due to the six grams of fiber, which Bourgeois actually liked. Fiber can be tough to digest, but it’s a crucial part of your daily diet and actually helps keep you satiated and promotes digestive regularity. (2)

“If ordered as a one-time purchase, you do have to shell out around $4.66 per serving,” Bourgeois said. “This is definitely a hefty cost compared to some other options out there.” And while you can save a little if you subscribe, we still have to give the price per serving a 1 out of 5. Unfortunately, this price point just isn’t realistic for most people.

[Related: The Best Types Of Supplements For Performance, Weight Loss, and Health]

Best Meal Replacement for Diabetes: 310 Meal Replacement Shake

310 Meal Replacement Shake
310 Meal Replacement Shake
310 Meal Replacement Shake

The 310 Meal Replacement Shakes offer a tri-plex blend of protein to control hunger, promote muscle growth, and has only two grams of net carbs and zero artificial sweeteners.

Shop Amazon

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 110 calories
  • Macros: 1.5-3g of fat, 6-7g of carbs, 15g of protein
  • Flavors: Strawberry, Tropical Coconut, Mocha, Horchata, Caramel Sundae, Chocolate Bliss, Cookies N’ Cream, Pumpkin Spice, Vanilla Creme, Organic Chocolate, Organic Salted Caramel, Organic Vanilla, Chocolate
  • Fiber per Serving: 5 grams
  • Sugar per Serving: 0 grams
  • Price per Serving: $3.21

Pros

  • Includes fiber for blood sugar control
  • Only 90 calories per serving
  • No artificial sweeteners

Cons

  • Not calorie-dense
  • Low in net carbs

Meal replacement shakes can offer metabolic benefits when incorporated into a well-balanced diet. (4)(5) Still, it’s imperative to note that people with diabetes speak to a physician or certified diabetes educator before trying any new supplements. This isn’t medical advice, but 310’s Meal Replacement Shake may be suitable for some adults living with diabetes. 

People with diabetes tend to prefer shakes with plenty of protein, fiber, and not much saturated fat or cholesterol. This shake offers 15 grams of protein and five grams of fiber with just two grams of net carbs per serving and no saturated fat or cholesterol at all.

However, we don’t love this as a real meal replacement. “The 310 Meal Replacement Shake scores a 2.5 out of 5 for its formulation,” according to Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, RD. “The macro ratio versus its costs leave you wanting more, and the proprietary blends leave you wondering what you’re actually drinking.”

310 Meal Replacement Shake in BarBend testing garage

While we don’t love this formula as a meal replacement shake, it can be a good low-carb snack to boost your protein intake. “I tried the variety pack and I liked the chocolate, mocha, and vanilla flavors,” our tester said, giving the taste a 4 out of 5. “But I’d recommend you stay away from the coconut. I couldn’t get down with that one.”

We didn’t exactly love the price point, unfortunately. One 28-serving bag costs $89.99, which is roughly $3.21 per serving. Considering you don’t get many calories with this shake, we had to give the overall value a 2 out of 5.

Read our full 310 Meal Replacement Shake Review.

Best Organic Meal Replacement Shake: Orgain Organic Nutritional Protein Shake

Orgain Organic Nutritional Protein Shake
Orgain Organic Nutritional Protein Shake
Orgain Organic Nutritional Protein Shake

These Orgain shakes are premade, making them a convenient shake to toss into your gym bag or sip in the car. They're USDA organic and non-GMO, too.

Shop Amazon

Specs

  • Calories per Serving: 250 calories
  • Macros: 8g of fat, 28g of carbs, 16g of protein
  • Flavors: Creamy Chocolate Fudge
  • Fiber per Serving: 1 gram
  • Sugar per Serving: 12 grams
  • Price per Serving: $2.37

Pros

  • All USDA Organic ingredients 
  • Pre-made and convenient
  • Has 20 different vitamins and minerals

Cons

  • Only 250 calories per serving
  • Low in protein

For those who want to prioritize organic ingredients, Orgain is certified organic and non-GMO. These pre-made meal replacement drinks are 250 calories per serving, including eight grams of fat, 28 grams of carbs, and 16 grams of protein per drink. Plus, you get 20 different vitamins and minerals, earning the formulation an overall 3.75 out of 5.

We do wish one serving had more calories, unfortunately. For a true meal replacement, 250 calories just won’t cut it. But we do love that there are no artificial sugars or sweeteners. And the protein comes from grass-fed whey, which we like.

Unfortunately, this product only comes in the Creamy Chocolate Fudge flavor, which isn’t necessarily ideal for everyone. So, for flavor variety, we had to give Orgain a 2 out of 5. Though, according to the many Amazon reviews, this one option is pretty tasty.

For solubility, this shake gets a perfect 5 out of 5 score, as it’s ready to drink. All you have to do is open the top and sip, which is super convenient. 

Orgain earned a 5 out of 5 for price per serving. One four-bottle package costs $9.48, which is only $2.37 per serving. This is definitely a budget-friendly pick for those who don’t want to spend too much on their meal replacement shake.

Benefits of Meal Replacements

Meal replacement supplements, like protein shakes and bars, can be an extremely efficient way to get a meal in. As with any supplement, though, there are pros and cons of meal replacements. Here are some of the reasons people will choose a meal replacement over whole foods. 

  • Convenience: A well-balanced meal replacement can keep you on your calorie and macro goals without having to run to the kitchen to whip up another meal. These are convenient for those on-the-go, too.
  • Extra Calories: Even if you don’t want to truly swap your meals for meal replacement shakes, these supplements are an easy way to increase your daily calorie intake.
  • Nutritional Value: Though some meal replacement shakes may be a little too low in calories to truly replace your lunch or breakfast, they do offer plenty of nutritional value. So, adding a shake to your daily routine can help supplement your daily diet.

How Much Do Meal Replacements Cost?

The prices of meal replacements vary based on container size and ingredients. In general, meal replacements with high-quality ingredients that don’t contain additives or artificial ingredients are going to be more expensive, as are higher-calorie meal replacements. Our list has picks that will cost between $2.49 to $4.66 per serving, but the average price per serving is around $3.11.

Best Meal Replacement ShakeKa’Chava Whole Body Meal$69.95 Per serving: $4.66
Best Meal Replacement Shake for Weight GainTransparent Labs Mass Gainer$79.99 Per serving: $5.33
Best Vegan Meal Replacement ShakeRootana$52.99 Per serving: $3.78
Best Keto Meal Replacement ShakeHLTH Code Complete Meal$59.95 Per serving: $4.00 
Best Meal Replacement Shake for Weight LossKa’Chava Whole Body Meal$69.95 Per serving: $4.66
Best Meal Replacement BarLegion High Protein Bar$39.99 Per serving: $3.33
Best-Tasting Meal Replacement ShakeHuel Black Edition$53 Per serving: $3.11
Best High-Protein Meal ReplacementKa’Chava Whole Body Meal$69.95 Per serving: $4.66
Best Meal Replacement Shake for Diabetes310 Meal Replacement Shake$89.99 Per serving: $3.21
Best Organic Meal Replacement ShakeOrgain Vegan Organic Nutrition Shake$9.48 Per serving: $2.37

On top of that, if the container has more servings, you’ll be paying more per order — though it’s more important to look at the price per serving to get an accurate sense of cost since container sizes vary by product. Overall, a container of meal replacements can cost anywhere from $40 to $100, depending on the brand and the contents.

What to Consider Before Buying a Meal Replacement

It can be a little daunting to look for products meant to replace a whole meal, not just one macronutrient, like a protein shake. Here are a few pointers to keep in mind when hunting for your next meal.

A BarBend tester shaking meal replacement drink.
A BarBend tester shaking meal replacement drink.

You may want to consider what a meal replacement is meant for, the calories, and satiety, as well as chatting with your healthcare provider if you have any questions or concerns. 

[Related: The 3 Most Effective Workouts Splits For Strength Training]

You’re Not Replacing Your Whole Diet

You should never live on meal replacements alone; the body needs phytochemicals, enzymes, and antioxidants that you’ll only get from whole foods. This attitude — that shakes are helpful, but not everything — should help to take the pressure off of finding the absolute perfect option.

Look at the Calories

When people consume too many calories, they gain weight, but if they don’t eat enough calories, they experience fatigue, nutrient deficiencies, and more. So before you buy the lowest calorie meal replacement on the market because you want to lose weight, ask yourself if it’s enough to keep hunger at bay and lower the odds of you overeating later. 

Make Sure It’s Satiating

If you’re trying to bulk up and gain a lot of muscle, this won’t apply to you. But if you want a shake to be satiating, consider not just the calories but also ensure there’s adequate protein, fiber, and fat, all of which are great for satisfying hunger.

Chat With a Doctor

Before making any changes to your diet and supplement regimen, like replacing a meal with powder, be sure to book an appointment with a physician or a registered dietitian to make sure it’s a good option for you.

[Related: The 5 Best Protein Chips On the Market]

Best Meal Replacement Shakes FAQs

Are meal replacement shakes healthy?

Good meal replacement shakes can be a healthy way to supplement a well-balanced diet. But it’s important to remember that they shouldn’t totally replace whole foods because they lack the variety of vitamins and minerals that you get with whole foods. You can use them as a way to increase your calorie intake or as an occasional meal in a pinch, but make sure you’re eating whole foods as well. 

Can a protein shake replace a meal?

A protein shake can replace a meal every now and then, but you’ll likely get hungry sooner than you would if you drank a meal replacement shake or if you ate a meal of whole foods. Protein shakes are useful for getting more protein, but they are usually low on carbohydrates, fats, and calories, as well as essential micronutrients that you’d get with whole foods. 

Can I use meal replacement shakes to lose weight?

Meal replacement shakes can be a convenient and easily measurable way to track calories, macronutrients, and micronutrients. Many people use them to help meet weight loss goals by tracking calories and hitting a calorie deficit. But like it or not, you only lose weight if you’re in a calorie deficit — that’s the main thing to be mindful of.

What is the best meal replacement option?

After trying out several different meal replacement products, we have landed on Ka’Chava Whole Body Meal as the best meal replacement option. Not only is it made with all-natural ingredients, but we love the flavors, the macros are well-balanced, and the addition of fiber may aid in digestion. Plus, it offers a solid 25 grams of protein per serving.

When should I use meal replacements?

This depends on your specific goals. You can use a meal replacement in place of any meal but it may be best to swap it with your least nutrient dense meal. For instance, if your breakfast tends to be a pastry, a meal replacement can help add vitamins and minerals to your diet. Or, if you’re trying to bulk, sipping a meal replacement shake between meals is another option.

References

  1. Bodke H, Jogdand S. Role of Probiotics in Human Health. Cureus. 2022;14(11):e31313. Published 2022 Nov 9. doi:10.7759/cureus.31313
  2. Gill SK, Rossi M, Bajka B, Whelan K. Dietary fibre in gastrointestinal health and disease. Nat Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2021;18(2):101-116. doi:10.1038/s41575-020-00375-4
  3. Min J, Kim SY, Shin IS, Park YB, Lim YW. The Effect of Meal Replacement on Weight Loss According to Calorie-Restriction Type and Proportion of Energy Intake: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2021;121(8):1551-1564.e3. doi:10.1016/j.jand.2021.05.001
  4. Boonyavarakul A, Leelawattana R, Pongchaiyakul C, Buranapin S, Phanachet P, Pramyothin P. Effects of meal replacement therapy on metabolic outcomes in Thai patients with type 2 diabetes: A randomized controlled trial. Nutr Health. 2018;24(4):261-268. doi:10.1177/0260106018800074.
  5. Kempf K, Röhling M, Niedermeier K, Gärtner B, Martin S. Individualized Meal Replacement Therapy Improves Clinically Relevant Long-Term Glycemic Control in Poorly Controlled Type 2 Diabetes Patients. Nutrients. 2018;10(8):1022. Published 2018 Aug 4. doi:10.3390/nu10081022
  6. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (n.d.). Vitamins and minerals for older adults. National Institute on Aging. https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/vitamins-and-minerals-older-adults. 
  7. Naderi A, de Oliveira EP, Ziegenfuss TN, Willems MT. Timing, Optimal Dose and Intake Duration of Dietary Supplements with Evidence-Based Use in Sports Nutrition. J Exerc Nutrition Biochem. 2016;20(4):1-12. doi:10.20463/jenb.2016.0031

About Nick English

Nick is a content producer and journalist with over seven years’ experience reporting on four continents. Since moving to New York City in 2013 he's been writing on health and fitness full time for outlets like BarBend, Men's Health, VICE, and Popular Science.

View All Articles

Primary Sidebar

Latest News

Eddie Hall’s 8,000-Calorie Carnivore Diet, Explained

5 Key Takeaways From Our Call With the PFAA About CrossFit Safety

Chris Bumstead Demolishes 150-Pound Incline Dumbbell Bench Press Ahead of 2024 Olympia

Terrence Ruffin Will Miss the 2024 Classic Physique Olympia

Take a Tour Through Wesley Vissers’ Vintage Gym

Latest Reviews

Pouring SEEQ into a glass from a blender bottle.

Seeq Protein Powder Review (2024): Advice From an R.D.

Our tester bites into a Power Crunch Bar

Power Crunch Bar Review (2024): RDs and Fitness Pros’ Insight

This gym bag is ready for the LMNT Review.

LMNT Review (2024): Insights From an RD

Our tester Drinks Field Of Greens

Brickhouse Nutrition Field of Greens Review (2024) — Assessed and Tested by Experts

Our tester holds up a C4 Energy Drink

C4 Energy Drink Review (2024): A Nutrition Coach’s Thoughts

BarBend

BarBend is an independent website. The views expressed on this site may come from individual contributors and do not necessarily reflect the view of BarBend or any other organization. BarBend is the Official Media Partner of USA Weightlifting.

  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest

Sections

  • CrossFit
  • Strongman
  • Bodybuilding
  • Powerlifting
  • Weightlifting
  • Reviews
  • Nutrition
  • Training

More

  • BarBend Newsletter
  • BarBend Podcast
  • The Ripped Report
  • 1RM Calculator
  • BMR Calculator
  • Macros Calculator
  • Protein Calculator
  • Squat Calculator

Policies

  • Accessibility
  • Advice Disclaimer
  • Cookies Policy
  • Disclaimers
  • Disclosures
  • Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Copyright © 2024 · BarBend Inc · Sitemap